The choice between a bank loan or fintech loan can be compared to deciding between a road paved decades ago and a new trail.
Advertisements
In other words, full of technology, but still under construction.
Each path has its advantages, challenges and peculiarities.
While traditional banks carry the trust of years of operation, fintechs bet on digital processes and accessibility to win customers.
But, after all, which of these options is the most advantageous for you?
This article explores the pros and cons of each modality, with intelligent arguments, practical examples and an approach that goes beyond the obvious, so you can make an informed decision.
1. Understanding the Fundamental Differences
First, it is crucial to understand what differentiates a loan banking of a loan with fintech.
Traditional banks operate with robust structures, regulated by the Central Bank, and offer a range of financial products, including personal, payroll and secured loans.
However, their processes tend to be more bureaucratic, requiring extensive documentation and, often, a prior relationship with the institution.
Furthermore, interest rates can vary significantly depending on the customer profile and type of credit.
On the other hand, fintechs, financial technology companies, have revolutionized the market with digital platforms that simplify access to credit.
Instead of queues and paperwork, they use algorithms and artificial intelligence to assess credit risk in minutes.
Therefore, they offer fast approval and, in some cases, competitive rates.
However, as they are newer players, many are still building their reputation, which can generate distrust among more conservative consumers.
So, does the agility of fintechs make up for the solidity of banks?
To illustrate, imagine two scenarios: Ana, a freelancer who needs R$5,000 to buy a new computer, and João, a civil servant who seeks R$50,000 to renovate his house.
Ana, without a solid banking history, finds a quick solution in fintechs, with approval in 24 hours and reasonable fees.
In turn, João, with a fixed salary and a high score, gets a loan secured from a bank with lower interest rates, but faces weeks of analysis.
In short, these examples show that the best choice depends on the individual context.
Table:
| Criterion | Bank loan | Loan with Fintech |
|---|---|---|
| Bureaucracy | High, requires extensive documentation | Download, process 100% online |
| Approval Time | 3 to 15 business days | 24 to 48 hours |
| Interest Rates (average) | 2% to 6% per month (varies by profile) | 1.5% to 8% per month (varies by platform) |
2. Advantages and Disadvantages: A Critical Look
Now that we understand the differences, let’s look at the strengths and weaknesses of each option.
In this sense, starting with the bank loans, a big advantage is security.
Banks such as Itaú, Bradesco or Banco do Brasil operate under strict regulations, which reduces the risk of fraud.
See also our article on: Home Business Ideas to Start with Little Money
In addition, they offer different options, such as payroll loans, which have lower rates (on average, 1.5% to 2% per month) as they are discounted directly from your salary.
However, the strictness of the approval criteria excludes many self-employed people or people with low credit scores.
In contrast, the fintechs shine for their accessibility.
Companies like Nubank, Creditas and Geru allow customers with limited financial history to apply for credit, thanks to alternative analysis models, such as online behavior data.
Furthermore, the user experience is a differentiator: everything is done via cell phone, without the need to visit a branch.
However, fees may be higher for higher risk profiles, and the lack of physical branches may make it difficult to receive support in case of problems.
A relevant statistic reinforces this discussion: according to the Central Bank (2023), the volume of credit granted by fintechs in Brazil grew 35% compared to the previous year, while traditional banks registered an increase of only 12%.
This suggests that fintechs are gaining traction, but it also raises the question: does popularity reflect quality or just ease of access?
In this sense, the answer depends on how you weigh factors such as cost, time and trust.
| Aspect | Bank loan | Loan with Fintech |
|---|---|---|
| Advantages | Security, lower rates for good payers, variety of modalities | Agility, accessibility, approval for different profiles |
| Disadvantages | Bureaucracy, exclusion of risk profiles | High fees for some, limited support |
3. Real Cost: Fees, Deadlines and Impact on Your Pocket
When it comes to bank loan or fintech loan, the effective cost is a decisive factor.
In banks, interest rates are influenced by the relationship with the customer and the type of loan.
For example, a personal loan may have interest of 4% per month, but a payroll loan may drop to 1.8%.
Furthermore, banks offer long terms, of up to 72 months, which reduces the installments, but increases the total cost due to accumulated interest.
Therefore, it is essential to calculate the Total Effective Cost (CET), which includes administrative fees and insurance.
Fintechs, although agile, are not always synonymous with savings.
Some, like Lendico, offer rates starting at 1.5% per month for low-risk customers, but less favorable profiles may face interest rates of up to 8%.
The terms, on the other hand, are generally shorter, from 12 to 36 months, which increases the value of the installments, but reduces the impact of interest in the long term.
Therefore, the choice requires careful analysis: do you prefer smaller installments or a lower total cost?
Consider the case of Mariana, who needed R$ 20,000 to open a small business.
At the bank, she obtained a loan with a CET of 3.5% per month, to be paid in 60 months, resulting in installments of R$ 650, but a total cost of R$ 39,000.
In fintech, the rate was 2.8% per month, but the maximum term was 24 months, with installments of R$ 1,050 and a total cost of R$ 25,200.
Mariana opted for fintech because the total cost was lower, even with higher installments.
In short, this example highlights the importance of comparing the APR and aligning the term with your payment capacity.
Table:
| Item | Bank loan | Loan with Fintech |
|---|---|---|
| Average CET | 2.5% to 6% per month | 1.5% to 8% per month |
| Average Term | 12 to 72 months | 12 to 36 months |
| Total Cost (R$ 20,000) | R$ 30,000 to R$ 45,000 (60 months) | R$ 23,000 to R$ 32,000 (24 months) |
4. User Experience and Accessibility
User experience is an area where fintechs often outperform banks.
Think of the credit application process as a journey: with a bank, it’s like taking an old, reliable, but slow and full of stops train.
You need to visit the agency, submit documents and wait weeks for approval.
With a fintech, it's like ordering a car through an app: fast, intuitive and straight from your cell phone.
This difference is especially relevant for the digital generation, which values practicality.
Furthermore, fintechs democratize access to credit.
While banks prioritize customers with a solid history, fintechs like Bom Para Crédito use alternative data, such as internet consumption and bill payments, to approve loans.
This is an advantage for young entrepreneurs or informal workers.
However, the lack of face-to-face interaction can be an obstacle for those who prefer human service, especially in cases of doubts or renegotiations.
So why are we still hesitant to embrace fintechs?
Perhaps because trust, built over decades by banks, still weighs more heavily for many.
However, with increasing regulation of fintechs by the Central Bank, this barrier is decreasing.
The choice, therefore, comes down to what you value most: the tradition of a bank or the innovation of a fintech?
| Criterion | Bank loan | Loan with Fintech |
|---|---|---|
| Request Channel | Agency, internet banking | Application, website |
| Target Audience | Clients with a solid track record | Various profiles, including informal ones |
| Support | In person and online | Online, with limitations |
5. Bank loan or fintech loan: Frequently Asked Questions
Below, we answer the most common questions about bank loan or fintech loan, to clarify your doubts and help you decide with confidence.
| Question | Response |
|---|---|
| Which option has the lowest interest rate? | It depends on the profile. Banks offer lower rates for loans, while fintechs can be more competitive for moderate risk profiles. |
| Are Fintechs safe? | Yes, as long as they are regulated by the Central Bank. Check the company's reputation before hiring. |
| Can I apply for a loan without a high score? | Fintechs are more flexible, but fees can be higher. Banks require better credit scores. |
| Which is faster? | Fintechs, with approval in up to 48 hours, compared to days or weeks at banks. |
| What if I can't pay? | Banks offer in-person renegotiation; fintechs, via digital platforms, but with less flexibility. |
Bank loan or fintech loan: Conclusion
Choose between one bank loan or fintech loan It’s more than comparing interest rates; it’s aligning your financial priorities with what each option offers.
Banks are ideal for those seeking security, long terms and competitive rates in modalities such as payroll loans.
Fintechs, on the other hand, are perfect for those who value agility, accessibility and uncomplicated processes.
The road and trail analogy sums it up nicely: banking is the tried-and-true path, while fintech is the innovative route.
Evaluate your profile, compare the APR and choose based on what makes sense for your situation. After all, the best loan is the one that fits your budget and your plans.
